How to Choose Shoemaking & Bagmaking Leather & Where to Buy It: The Complete Beginner's Guide

How to Choose Shoemaking & Bagmaking Leather & Where to Buy It: The Complete Beginner's Guide

One of the questions we're asked more than almost any other is:

"What leather should I buy?"

It sounds like a simple question, but unfortunately the answer isn't as straightforward as most people hope.

Many beginners assume the most important thing is choosing the correct thickness.

In reality, thickness is only one small part of the picture.

The characteristic that usually has the biggest impact on how enjoyable your project is to make is temper.

A leather with the perfect thickness but the wrong temper can be frustrating to work with, while a leather with the right temper will stretch beautifully over a shoe last and make the whole process significantly easier.

Whether you're making shoes, boots or even handbags, this guide will explain what really matters when choosing leather, along with some of our favourite suppliers around the world.

These are starting recommendations rather than fixed rules.

In our experience, the temper of the leather has a much bigger impact on how enjoyable it is to work with than the thickness alone.

The biggest mistake beginners make

One of the most common emails we receive says something like:

"Can you just tell me exactly what thickness leather I need?"

We wish it were that simple.

Thickness certainly matters, but it's only one part of the story.

We've seen two pieces of leather that are both exactly 1 mm thick behave completely differently when lasting over a shoe.

One stretches beautifully.

The other fights you every step of the way.

The difference isn't the thickness.

It's the temper.

 

What is leather temper?

Temper describes how soft or firm a leather feels and how it behaves when you work with it.

This is one of the most important characteristics to understand because it determines how easily the leather stretches, folds and holds its shape.

Soft temper

Soft temper leather has flexibility and natural stretch.

Depending on the thickness this can often be too soft for shoes, think gloves or a floppy garment.

Medium temper

Medium temper leather offers a balance between flexibility and structure.

It's much easier to stretch over a shoemaking last, making it an excellent choice for beginners and for softer, more relaxed bags.

Best for:

  • Women's shoes

  • Boots

  • Trainers

  • Slouchy handbags

Stiff temper

Firm leather holds its shape exceptionally well.

That's exactly what you want when making a structured handbag.

However, that same firmness makes it much harder to stretch over a shoe last.

For that reason, we generally don't recommend firm leather for beginners learning shoemaking.

 

Shoes vs bags

Although shoes and handbags are often made from similar materials, they behave very differently.

Leather for shoes

Shoes need leather that can stretch around the curves of the last while still maintaining some structure, but not too much structure… (Blisters anyone!)

That means we're usually looking for leather that is:

  • Soft to medium temper

  • Flexible

  • Has a small amount of natural stretch

  • Comfortable to wear

If the leather is too stiff, lasting becomes much more difficult and the finished shoe can feel stiff or uncomfortable.

Leather for structured handbags

Structured handbags need the opposite.

Rather than stretching, they need to hold their shape.

For this reason we'd usually recommend:

  • Firm temper leather

  • Approximately 1.2-1.4 mm thick

  • Leather with good body and structure

The leather itself becomes part of the bag's structure.

Leather for slouchy handbags

If you're making a relaxed tote or slouchy shoulder bag, you want the leather to drape naturally.

Look for:

  • Soft - Medium temper

  • Around 1.2-1.4 mm thick

  • Natural movement

  • A softer handle

It's the temper, rather than the thickness, that creates that beautiful slouch.

Chrome tanned vs vegetable tanned leather

This is probably one of the biggest misconceptions in leathercraft.

Many people assume that vegetable tanned leather is simply the environmentally friendly version of leather, while chrome tanned leather is the less sustainable alternative.

The reality is far more nuanced.

Chrome tanned leather

Chrome tanned leather is used in the vast majority of modern shoes, handbags and fashion accessories.

It tends to be:

  • Softer

  • More flexible

  • Easier to stretch over a last

  • More resistant to moisture

  • Available in a huge variety of colours and finishes

For almost every beginner shoemaking project, this is what we'd recommend.

Its flexibility makes lasting much easier and gives beginners a much more forgiving material to work with.

Vegetable tanned leather

Vegetable tanned leather uses tannins derived from plant materials rather than chromium salts.

While many people assume this automatically makes it the environmentally friendly option, leather production is a complex process and vegetable tanning still involves a wide range of chemicals, water and energy.

It's not quite as simple as "vegetable equals sustainable."

Vegetable tanned leather is generally:

  • Firmer

  • Less stretchy

  • More structured

  • Malleable when wet

It has a well-deserved place in traditional leathercraft, particularly for belts, wallets and saddlery.

For shoemaking, however, we rarely use it.

Years ago we regularly used vegetable tanned leather for leather outsoles.

Today we almost always choose modern resin sole materials instead because we find them more durable, more consistent and better suited to the types of shoes our students are making.

For the same reason, we don't generally recommend vegetable tanned leather for beginners making shoes or handbags.

Its firmer temper makes it significantly less forgiving than chrome tanned leather.


What about vegan leather?

This is one of the questions we're asked more and more often.

When people say "vegan leather", they're often referring to two very different materials.

Synthetic leather

The most common vegan leathers are synthetic materials made from polyurethane (PU) or PVC.

They're widely available and can work well for both shoes and bags.

However, they're petroleum-based materials and shouldn't automatically be considered the sustainable option.

If you're choosing a synthetic leather, there's one feature we pay more attention to than anything else.

Turn it over.

Look at the backing.

Some synthetic leathers have a woven fabric backing.

Others have a backing that more closely resembles suede.

Whenever possible, choose the suede-effect backing.

The reason is simple.

Fabric-backed synthetic leather tends to absorb contact adhesive, making it difficult to achieve a clean, reliable bond.

A suede-like backing behaves much more like natural leather, allowing the adhesive to sit on the surface properly and creating a much stronger bond.

If you're buying synthetic leather for your first pair of shoes, this is probably the single biggest piece of advice we can give.

 

Plant-based leather alternatives

In recent years we've seen some incredibly exciting developments in leather alternatives, including materials made from:

  • Pineapple fibres

  • Mushroom mycelium

  • Apple waste

  • Cactus

  • Grape waste

  • Corn-based materials

It's a fascinating area of the industry and one we're watching with great interest.

However, from the perspective of someone teaching home shoemakers, we don't think these materials are quite there yet.

Most are still difficult to buy in small quantities, often expensive, and are generally aimed at commercial manufacturers rather than independent makers.

As these materials become easier to source and more suitable for home makers, we'll happily update this guide with suppliers we'd recommend.

Our favourite leather for lining

One leather has become our default choice for almost everything we make.

Ballet from GH Leathers.

We use it for:

  • Shoe linings

  • Boot linings

  • Handbag linings

It's beautifully consistent, soft to work with and performs exceptionally well across a wide range of projects.

If you're unsure what lining leather to choose, it's an excellent place to start.

 

Where to buy leather in the UK

The UK has some outstanding leather suppliers, whether you're making shoes, boots or handbags.

GH Leathers

Best for: Footwear leather and lining leather.

GH Leathers is one of our favourite suppliers and has been our go-to for many years.

In particular, we highly recommend Ballet, which has become our preferred lining leather for almost every project we teach.

GH also stocks an excellent range of upper leathers suitable for both shoes and handbags.

A A Crack

One of the UK's longest-established leather merchants, A A Crack offers an enormous selection of leathers suitable for footwear, leather goods and upholstery. We love it for bag leathers too.

It's an excellent place to browse once you have a better understanding of the type of leather you're looking for.


Where to buy leather in Europe

If you're happy buying online, Europe has some of the best leather suppliers in the world. Many of them stock leathers from the same Italian tanneries used by luxury fashion houses, making them an excellent option for both hobbyists and professionals.

BuyLeatherOnline.com

Best for: A huge range of leather with great prices and international shipping.

If we had to recommend just one European supplier for beginners, BuyLeatherOnline would be high on the list. Mainly because they list the thickness, the temper and recommended usage for each of the products. Plus they have some really cool styles!

Based in Italy, they stock an enormous range of leathers suitable for shoes, boots and handbags, including:

  • Smooth calf leather

  • Suede

  • Printed leathers

  • Metallic finishes

  • Vegetable tanned leather

  • Chrome tanned leather

  • Bag-making leather

  • Linings

They also ship internationally, making them a popular choice for makers all over the world.

 

Where to buy leather in the USA

The United States has a number of excellent leather suppliers, particularly for footwear and leathercraft.

Global Leathers - New York

Best for: Footwear leather and fashion leathers.

Global Leathers has long been a favourite of ours when visiting New York.

They stock an excellent range of leathers suitable for both shoes and handbags, with plenty of choice in colours, finishes and textures.

If you're looking for fashion leathers rather than heavy leathercraft hides, they're well worth a visit.

 

Rocky Mountain Leather Supply

Best for: Premium leather and hardware.

Rocky Mountain Leather Supply has become one of the most respected leather suppliers in North America.

Although many people know them for leathercraft, they also stock beautiful leathers suitable for footwear and handbags, alongside high-quality hardware and tools.

The product descriptions are detailed, making it easier to understand what you're buying before ordering.

 

District Leather Supply

Best for: Fashion leather and small quantity purchases.

District Leather Supply has built a strong reputation amongst independent makers thanks to its carefully curated range of premium leathers.

If you're making one or two pairs of shoes or a small number of bags, it's an excellent supplier to have on your list.

 

Tandy Leather

Best for: Leathercraft tools and general leather supplies.

Tandy Leather is one of the largest leather retailers in North America.

While we wouldn't necessarily recommend it as your first choice for fashion shoe leather, it's an excellent resource for leathercraft tools, accessories and general workshop supplies.

 

Where to buy leather in Australia

Australia has fewer specialist footwear leather suppliers than Europe, but there are still several excellent businesses worth knowing.

Leffler Leather Merchants

Best for: Footwear and handbag leather.

Leffler is probably the supplier we'd recommend first to most Australian makers.

They stock a wide range of chrome tanned leathers suitable for shoes, boots and handbags, alongside tools, adhesives and other leatherworking materials.

Because they cater to both hobbyists and professionals, they're an excellent place to begin building your leather collection.

 

Birdsall Leather

Best for: Leathercraft and bag making.

Birdsall has been supplying Australian leatherworkers for decades.

They offer a broad selection of leathers alongside tools and hardware, making them particularly useful if you're making handbags as well as shoes.

 

Packer Leather

Best for: Premium Australian leather.

Packer Leather is one of Australia's best-known tanneries and produces high-quality leather used throughout the footwear industry.

If you're interested in Australian-made leather, they're definitely worth exploring.

 

Can I buy leather online?

Absolutely.

In fact, most professional shoemakers regularly buy leather online.

The key is buying from suppliers who provide enough information to help you understand how the leather will behave.

Look for descriptions that include:

  • Thickness

  • Temper

  • Tannage

  • Finish

  • Intended use

The more information a supplier provides, the easier it is to choose the right leather without seeing it in person.

If you're unsure, don't be afraid to contact the supplier. A good leather merchant should be able to tell you whether a leather is suitable for shoes, boots or handbags.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

What thickness leather should I use for shoes?

For most women's shoes and boots, we'd recommend starting with leather between 0.7 mm and 1.2 mm thick.

However, don't choose leather based on thickness alone. In our experience, the temper of the leather is far more important than the number on the specification sheet.

 

Is softer leather better for shoes?

Generally, yes.

Leather with a soft to medium temper is much easier to stretch over a shoe last, making it more forgiving for beginners.

 

What's the best leather for handbag making?

That depends on the style of bag.

For structured handbags, we'd recommend a firmer leather around 1.2-1.4 mm thick.

For slouchy bags, we'd choose a softer leather of a similar thickness that has more natural movement and drape.

 

Should I use vegetable tanned leather?

For most beginners, we'd say no.

Vegetable tanned leather has many wonderful qualities, but it's generally firmer and less forgiving than chrome tanned leather.

For the types of shoes and bags we teach, we almost always choose chrome tanned leather instead.

 

Can I use upholstery leather?

Sometimes, but be careful.

Many upholstery leathers are beautifully soft but can also be very stretchy, which isn't always ideal for footwear.

Whenever possible, choose leather that's intended for shoes or handbags rather than furniture.

 

What leather do you use at I Can Make Shoes?

Our favourite lining leather is Ballet from GH Leathers, which we use for almost all of our shoe, boot and handbag projects.

For upper leather, the choice depends entirely on the project, but we almost always favour chrome tanned leather with an appropriate temper over simply choosing a leather based on thickness.

 

Final thoughts

If there's one thing we'd like every beginner to remember, it's this:

Don't choose your leather by thickness alone.

Choose it by how it behaves.

A leather that's soft enough to stretch comfortably over a shoe last will usually make your first pair of shoes far more enjoyable to build than a thicker, stiffer leather.

Likewise, a beautifully structured handbag starts with a leather that wants to hold its shape, while a relaxed tote depends on a softer leather with natural drape.

Understanding temper is one of the biggest steps from simply buying leather to choosing the right leather.

Once you start thinking that way, selecting leather becomes much easier.

And finally, don't feel you need to find the "perfect" leather before you begin. Every shoemaker develops their own favourites over time.

Start with a reputable supplier, choose a leather that's appropriate for your project, and begin making. Your hands will teach you more about leather than any article ever could.